Should I Replace My Garage Door Motor?

Jan 12, 2025

Many people take their garage door motor for granted as it works consistently for an extended period of time, often for decades before experiencing any issues that would make you need to repair or replace it. Once your garage motor slows down or stops working completely, it comes out of nowhere and can be a bigger headache at that moment than you might realize. Instead of waiting for this moment to happen and you not having a garage door that works (possibly closing in a vehicle or not allowing one in), it’s best to be on the look out of signs that it’s time to replace your garage door motor. In this article, we’ll go through the 3 main signs it may be time for a new motor. 

3 Signs it’s Time to Upgrade Your Garage Door Motor

Shuts Off Completely

If your garage door motor shuts off and will not turn back on or restart, the motor may have an issue where it’s no longer receiving the power needed to operate correctly. You can first try to reset your motor along with unplugging and plugging back in to determine if it’s an issue with the motor not receiving power. Another cause could be fried internal components. Older models usually cannot keep up with the power demand, causing the motor to work harder and harder – ultimately causing a shortage of electrical components. 

Slow or Weak Pull

You may notice a screeching or grinding noise when opening and closing your garage door which normally happens when there is excess demand on the motor, which will cause the door to open and close slowly. Eventually, the excess strain on the motor will cause the motor to shut off and not work at all. This could be incredibly dangerous if it shuts off during a cycle as it could collapse causing injury or damage which we always want to avoid. Should you notice a slow or weak pull by the motor, or any peculiar noises, it may be time for an upgrade as this is a sign it’ll likely shut off completely soon.  

Flickering Lights When Using

In addition to a slow or weak pull, your garage door motor lights may flicker when the motor is under increased stress from working to lift the door or lower it slowly. Both the light for the garage, as well as the small light(s) on the back of the motor may flicker. This should be an immediate warning sign it may be time for a motor replacement. The longer the flickering continues, the higher the chance of an electrical or mechanical failure.

garage door motor that the lights are flickering

Conclusion

The typical garage door motor will last between 10-15 years and sometimes last as long as 20+ years. Here at Today Garage Door Services, we recommend a replacement or upgrade every 10 years to make sure you don’t experience a mechanical or electrical failure during use. In addition, you will want to ensure the motor is keeping up with the current power demand especially if you get new springs, cables, tracks, or a new garage door.

We’re Here to Help

We hope we were able to assist in helping determine the source of the air leak. We understand it is frustrating having an issue that isn’t able to be identified easily. Again, should you determine you need a seal replacement or total door replacement, give us a call today! 

Having other issues? Look at our other resources for potential help

Why Won’t My Garage Stay Warm?

Have you discovered your garage suddenly feels cooler? Are you noticing the contents of your garage are cold to the touch? This article will walk you through the 4 main causes and solutions to make sure the garage is properly temperature regulated.  4 Reasons Why...

Garage Door Cables: Function, Importance, and Replacement

Garage door cables are essential to the performance of your garage door. They ensure your door opens and closes smoothly, efficiently, and more importantly, safely. Should your cables fail, you can find yourself in a very dangerous situation. The goal of this page is...

Why is my Garage Door Stuck Open?

Did you just discover your garage door won’t close after opening? We receive many frantic phone calls from customers who have found themselves in this scenario. This issue could be a result of many things, most of which can be fixed easily. Let’s explore the the most...

Why is my Garage Door Remote Not Working?

Did your garage door remote suddenly quit working? Does your remote require multiple presses for it to work? Either of these occurrences may seem sudden, but just like all other equipment, your remote has a set lifespan. Let’s explore a few issues and how you can fix...

Guide to Maintaining Your Garage

We all want to extend the life of the things we own and it should be no different when it comes to your garage. Most people tend to perform little to no maintenance on their garage whether it’s out of laziness or simply not aware of its benefits. Many components of...

Garage Flooring – Which Is Best For Me? 

Are you in the market for a new garage floor but not sure what your options are? We've all been there, just like trying to choose the ideal garage door, and that's why we wrote this article, so we can help make this decision a bit more simple for you. A few things to...

New Garage Construction – A Guide To Choosing The Ideal Garage Door 

Is building a garage in the plans for your next project? Whether you’re looking to take down your current garage and rebuild or you’re a new home/landowner and are starting from scratch we have a few things that you should consider and we’ll help address those for...

Garage Door Has Power, But Isn’t Working?

Are you experiencing issues with your garage door opening, even though you know it has power? We’ve all been there. It’s a headache that can be tough to figure out and continues to cause issues that you don’t get why they are there.  If you’re finding yourself...

The Importance of Garage Door Seals

Many people overlook the importance of the garage door seal and underestimate the impact a damaged seal really can have on the garage space and the potential of garage door repairs. We will explore how to tell if your seal is damaged or old as well as the things you...

How Does Weather Affect My Garage Door? 

Here in the desert, the weather tends to be predictable with the same weather patterns year over year. While you may not consider weather to be much of a factor on the wear and tear of your garage door, it can actually be a pretty big factor. There are different...
Table of Contents